Doug Bloomfield won his eighth bid for Goshen town supervisor on Tuesday, beating his Democratic challenger, Ken Newbold, 1,337 to 1,187.
Newbold, a town councilman, has served on the board for decades.
Democrat Phil Canterino won one of two open seats on the board, where he had served in the past, with 1,316 votes. Republican Richard D. Florio Jr., a newcomer, won the other seat with 1,216 votes.
They beat town board candidates John VanDerMolen Jr., the Republican incumbent, who won 1,104 votes; and newcomer Zachary Constantine, a Democrat, who won 1,149 votes.
The top vote-getter in the Town of Goshen Tuesday was Republican incumbent Priscilla Gersbeck, who won re-election to the town clerk's position with 1,809 votes. She ran unopposed.
Two other Republican incumbents ran unopposed: town justice Rory Brady, who won 1,771 votes; and highway supervisor P. Broderick Knoell, who won 1,793 votes.