When law enforcement doesn't play by the rules, it erodes faith in our justice system

Make text smaller Make text larger

To the Editor:

For those in law enforcement, the word "Brady" is considered the kiss of death. It means you are on a list held by the district attorney’s office because something happened in your career indicating your integrity was questionable. In terms of testifying, 99 percent of the time the district attorney’s office will do anything to not let that officer on the witness stand. Doing so may mean disclosing the witnesses’ past untruthfulness.

In early December, a trial was held in Orange County regarding a Newburgh home invasion. A police officer who was subpoenaed was on the Brady list. The district attorney’s office, already facing claims of prosecutorial misconduct in the trial, kept that to themselves in their attempt to secure a conviction. In this case, a vicious felony assault was knocked down to tampering with evidence.

Law enforcement/district attorneys should remember that when they don’t play by the rules. It erodes faith in a justice system that we are told to blindly trust. Someday it could be you or someone you love facing an overzealous prosecutor that is more concerned with their conviction record than what is right. That’s why we need criminal justice reform.

Roger Roth

New York, N.Y.

Make text smaller Make text larger


Pool Rules


New York Gov. Cuomo to urge Trump to rethink tax changes
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo visited the White House on Feb. 12 to urge President Donald Trump to rethink a provision in the 2017 tax overhaul that Cuomo says is prompting a sharp...
Read more »

Can we talk? No I didn't think so
To the Editor:
Can we talk...No I didn't think so.
Logic premise: All conservatives are either racists, homophobes, Nazis or sexists.
Pete is a...

Read more »

Inspire teachers and staff strike for better wages
Teachers and staff at Inspire — a nonprofit that provides education...

Read more »

New senior center does not solve wait-list problem
By Ginny Privitar
— Officials said for years that Chester needed to build a new senior center because the seniors' old meeting...

Read more »


Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Community Newspapers


Local News
Goshen's Historic Track needs help
  • Feb 20, 2019
Corey J. Mayo dies at age 73
  • Feb 20, 2019


Find more about Weather in Chester, NY