Five years after Sandy, New York state is still not ready for disaster

Make text smaller Make text larger


  • A tree was uprooted on Elm Street in Warwick during Sandy, which made landfall in the U.S. on Oct. 30, 2012. (Photo by Robert G Breese)

(AP) Each time a massive hurricane slammed into the coastlines of our islands and Southern states in the last two months, a familiar feeling of dread and vulnerability returned to Long Islanders.

Even five years after superstorm Sandy pummeled Long Island, five years after the water receded, and boardwalks were rebuilt, many homes elevated, dunes recreated and infrastructure reconstructed, that vulnerability remains.

Certainly, state and local officials have done much to rebuild in smarter and better ways, to try to protect, however temporarily, our shorelines. Plans for how to respond to such emergencies have gotten smarter. And the infrastructure of our power grid and other electrical equipment is much stronger. But all of these don't substitute for a region-wide effort to plan for the next big one.

Take the Governor's Office of Storm Recovery, a department set up in 2013 to combine recovery and rebuilding under a single umbrella. That effort has been specific to Sandy, officials in that office noted. Its duties are about rebuilding from destruction, not about broader thinking about our region's resiliency or plans for the future. Even though individuals are having those conversations, that's not enough.

We have to continue to help those whose homes were ravaged by Sandy, and we have to complete the larger reconstruction projects. A prime example is repairs needed to the East River train tunnels damaged by Sandy's corrosive floodwaters — an effort whose launch has now been put off to 2025.

But attention must be paid. Harvey, Irma and Maria didn't hit Long Island, but could have with a few different turns. It's only a matter of time.

Enter the notion of a regional or statewide coastal commission. Similar to the California Coastal Commission, such an organization would work with municipalities to regulate development to determine what's best for the shoreline, plan for future massive weather events and, fundamentally, think differently and bigger than we've ever thought before. The Regional Plan Association, a Manhattan-based nonprofit public policy organization, suggested earlier this month that such an agency would work across state lines, handling coastal and environmental concerns from New York to New Jersey to Connecticut. That might be a complicated endeavor, but it should be started. The first priority should be to establish a state umbrella agency to bring New York municipalities together to devise a master plan. All that would take would be an act of the State Legislature and a signature from Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo.

From Staten Island to Montauk, from Throgs Neck to Orient, we need to assess the needs, gather and address the best ideas, and then put them in place. The storms will surge, the tides will rise. Let's not wait until the next one to respond.


Make text smaller Make text larger


Pool Rules


Goshen students learn basics of computer programming
— Goshen Central School District students in grades K-8 joined more than 100 million students from around the world to learn the...
Read more »

10 things you should know about cervical cancer
No woman should die of cervical cancer. It is highly preventable with regular screening tests and appropriate follow-up care. It also can be cured when found early and...
Read more »

Rule number one: 'No life is worth the fish'
By David Dye
A small cluster of ice huts stood alone as the wind swept over the ice covering the Shenango River Lake on a recent afternoon. But spirits inside the huts were...

Read more »

Healthy You 2018

Read more »


* indicates required
Community Newspapers


Local News
Chester plans flower show trip
  • Jan 18, 2018


Find more about Weather in Chester, NY