Teen girl admits strangling 81-year-old woman in break-in

Jennifer Molyneaux also admits to hitting and smothering Helen Mills in her Green Street home

Make text smaller Make text larger


  • Jennifer Molyneaux

— A teenage girl has pleaded guilty to strangling an 81-year-old woman while burglarizing the victim's Goshen home before setting it on fire.

Orange County District Attorney David Hoovler announced on Feb. 26 that Jennifer Molyneaux, 17, of the Town of Wallkill pleaded guilty to second-degree murder for having killed Helen Mills during a botched robbery at Mills' Green Street home on Aug. 2.

On Feb. 25, Molyneaux admitted to Orange County Court Judge Nicholas De Rosa that she had entered Mills' residence with the intention of stealing money. She also admitted to placing her hands on the elderly woman’s throat, hitting her, and smothering her with a pillow before gasoline was spread around the house and set ablaze. Molyneaux said she had taken drugs before committing the crime.

Before Molyneaux pleaded guilty, prosecutors told Judge De Rosa that the District Attorney’s Office would be recommending a sentence of 25 years to life in state prison, Hoovler said. Molyneaux is scheduled to be sentenced on May 1.

“There is a nexus between illicit narcotics and violent crime,” said Hoovler. “It is utterly reprehensible that anyone would kill a defenseless, elderly, woman in her own bedroom. My office will strongly recommend that a sentence of 25 years to life in prison be imposed on this defendant. We must hold accountable those who violently victimize defenseless citizens to get money to feed their drug habits.”

Devin Giordano, 19, of the Village of Goshen, was indicted by a grand jury along with Molyneaux. He is scheduled to appear in county court on March 2.

Investigation finds foul playOn Aug. 2, 2014, at approximately 4 a.m., the Village of Goshen Police Department and the Goshen Fire Department responded to a structure fire at the victim’s two-story residence at 84 Green St. in the village. An autopsy found that Mills suffered blunt force trauma wounds on her head, and throat injuries consistent with her having been beaten and strangled.

It was apparent to the village police, which did the initial investigation, that Mills was the victim of a homicide. The village reached out to the New York State Police and asked that the investigation be conducted jointly with the state police and the Orange County Fire Investigations Unit. Evidence indicating the use of fire accelerants was found in several locations inside Mills' residence, including in her bedroom, in the vicinity where her body was found.

An Orange County Grand Jury indicted Molyneaux and Giordano with second-degree murder, first-degree burglary, and first-degree arson.

District Attorney Hoovler thanked the Village of Goshen Police Department, the state police, and Orange County Fire Investigations Unit for their investigation of this case.

The case is being prosecuted by Assistant District Attorneys Leah Canton and Christopher Kelly.

Make text smaller Make text larger


Pool Rules


Study: More students default on loans at for-profit schools
A new report finds that students attending for-profit colleges in New York state are more than twice as likely to default on their loans as those at non-profit schools.

Read more »

Property tax exemption for farmers extended another 10 years
A tax emption that's deemed essential for farmers and growers across New York state has been extended for another decade.
Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced Dec. 5 that the state's...

Read more »

School lunch rules OK refined grains, low-fat chocolate milk
By Candice Choi
The U.S. school lunch program is making room on menus again for noodles, biscuits, tortillas and other foods made mostly of refined grains.
The Trump...

Read more »

Dutchess joins handful of NY counties banning plastic bags
POUGHKEEPSIE — Dutchess County has joined a handful of New York counties banning or requiring fees for single-use plastic bags.
Read more »


Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Community Newspapers


Find more about Weather in Chester, NY